A "Marriage" of Fact and Fiction – Giveaway

By Carol / April 28, 2015 /

Many authors write a memoir first and then turn to fiction, as I did. While those first works of fiction often have some basis in real people and events, the outcome is largely fictional as the author molds the story line, characters, and events to achieve the best dramatic arc.

Susan Weidener’s new novel A Portrait of Love and Honor is a unique combination of fact and fiction because it’s based on her late-husband’s unpublished memoir. To celebrate the launch, Susan is giving away a copy of her new novel to readers of this blog. All you have to do to enter is leave a comment.

I had the pleasure of meeting Susan in Tucson this spring where she writes and leads memoir workshops. Here is her story.

A “Marriage” of Fact and Fiction

By Susan G. Weidener

A Portrait of Love and Honor, cover I first made the decision to publish my late husband John M. Cavalieri’s memoir in 2013. As I looked out the kitchen window at a dreary gray Pennsylvania morning, I thought of John’s story. While he had tried to get it published before his death in 1994, it was rejected by traditional publishers. I always felt it both compelling and beautifully written. It seemed a waste to let it gather dust in the back of my closet.

I went upstairs and took Life with Honor from a carton with John’s West Point memorabilia; his yearbook, and the black and white photographs of him and fellow cadets. . . the track team for company G-1 where John was captain . . . John in full dress uniform. I read late into the morning. John was again in the room with me.

A thought took shape. What if I created a fictionalized love story to “embrace” John’s memoir of West Point? I visualized Jay Scioli (John’s pen name) meeting a 40-something divorced editor and author, Ava Stuart. Jay admires Ava’s writing and at a book signing approaches her about editing his memoir. As they work on it, they discover that indefinable chemistry and connection of two people searching for meaning and love in a life often marred with disillusionment and adversity. Thus, A Portrait of Love and Honor emerged over a two-year period of writing and rewriting.

Although I am a journalist and memoirist, fiction was no stranger to me. Between my sophomore and junior years in college, I wrote a historical romance set in the Court of King Charles II. After college, I worked on a contemporary novel – a thinly veiled memoir about a young woman who falls in love with the wrong guy and then travels solo across England, France and Holland searching for stories in her quest to become a writer.


Susan & John Cavalieri

Susan & John Cavalieri

John wrote his memoir in 1991 and 1992. In 1994, three weeks after his 47th birthday, he died of colorectal cancer. Upon rereading his story, I felt important questions remained unanswered.  So I had to imagine what “Jay” might say in relation to his parents and their expectations . . . and his own desire to remain at the United States Military Academy at West Point against all odds.

I excerpted portions of the memoir, choosing those sections I felt most dramatic. I tried to intensify John’s experience at the Academy with more detailed writing and descriptions of the Hudson River Valley, the Academy during bleak winters, and more vivid character descriptions of the cadets who served as the centerpiece to his story.

Thus, a marriage of fact and fiction: a novel based on a true story.


My years as a journalist also taught me the importance of accuracy. I researched and double-checked what John wrote about West Point – how many graduates of the Class of 1966 died in Vietnam; the history, abuses and abolishment of the Fourth Class System – a form of hazing of plebes; who gave the commencement address for the Class of 1971. It helped, of course, that John and I had visited the Academy many times when we were married and talked often of his years there. My husband is buried in the Catholic cemetery overlooking the Hudson River at USMA. I have been back just once in 20 years to visit his gravesite. I plan another trip to the Academy this spring.


The setting of my novel is drawn from landscapes I most love: Chester County, Pennsylvania, where I live, and Tucson, Arizona, where I have been coming in winters to write and reflect. John and I never traveled to Tucson so the scenes between Jay and Ava that take place there are pure fiction.

Moving from memoir to fiction offered me a creative expression and vision for my husband’s story. I felt it showcased John’s memoir, making it more appealing to today’s readers. It also offered me the opportunity to craft a dramatic story . . . and while drawn from my own life with John, the story of two people destined to meet took on a life of its own.

Things I have learned:

  • Write with imagination, heart and soul
  • Do your research
  • Create dramatic characters whose lives ring true
  • Add conflict throughout the story
  • Avoid excessive back story
  • Create realistic dialogue
  • Keep the story moving
  • Be creative and have a vision for your novel


**Don’t forget to leave a comment for a chance to win a *free copy* of A Portrait of Love and Honor. The winner may choose either paperback or ebook. The drawing will be held on May 15, 2015.

Susan hosts the Women’s Writing Circle, a welcoming and encouraging site for writers. I encourage you to check out her blog and all of her books. You can get your copy of A Portrait of Love and Honor  NOW on Amazon in paperback or on Kindle, and at Barnes & Noble.

Susan Weidener

Susan Weidener

Author Bio: Susan G. Weidener is the author of two memoirs, Again in a Heartbeat, a memoir of love, loss and dating again, and the sequel to that, Morning at Wellington Square. A former reporter with The Philadelphia Inquirer, Susan has interviewed a host of interesting people from all walks of life, including Guy Lombardo, Bob Hope, Leonard Nimoy and Mary Pipher. Susan earned a BA in Literature from American University and a master’s in education from the University of Pennsylvania. An editor, writing coach and teacher of writing workshops, Susan founded the Women’s Writing Circle, a support and critique group for writers in suburban Philadelphia. She lives in Chester Springs, PA.

Her website is:

Amazon Author Page

Twitter @Sweideheart



Subscribe below for blog updates

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Posted in



  1. Kathleen Pooler on April 28, 2015 at 11:07 pm

    Susan, thank you for taking us on your creative journey of the story behind the story of this beautiful novel you have crafted from John’s memoir. This makes your story unique in that John’s voice plays a prominent part in the story. I love your tips, especially #1 “write with imagination, heart and soul.” Both you and Carol have shown us how this is done through your writings. Thank you Carol for featuring Susan and helping her promote her novel. I’m excited to feature you,,Susan on my blog on 5/18.

    • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 10:52 am

      It’s a particular treat to know Susan through her writing and to have met her in person. As I do you, Kathy. I’m delighted to help Susan launch her novel since I enjoyed both her memoirs so much.

    • Susan Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:26 am

      Hi Kathy, Thank you for your ongoing support. I’m excited that we’re going to talk about “breaking the rules” in writing on your May 18 blog post.

  2. Susan G. Weidener on April 29, 2015 at 7:37 am

    Carol, Thanks so much for featuring what I wrote and what went into A Portrait of Love and Honor. I also enjoyed spending time with you this past February in Tucson under sunny, high skies . . . much like those I wrote about in the book where Jay and Ava find in each other meaning in a life that often seems so trivial and pointless.

    I look forward to comments and sharing a copy of the book with one of your readers. With gratitude . . . Susan

    • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:07 am

      Delighted to have you share your story with my readers. It’s not often I get to meet in person the authors I host. Having met you makes this visit so much more meaningful.

  3. mary gottschalk on April 29, 2015 at 8:55 pm

    Susan’s authorial voice has grown over the years … I have been looking forward to this book … and even more so based on this interview/commentary.

    Is there a new genre here?

    • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:00 am

      I agree with you, Mary. Susan’s writing grows richer with each book.

      Susan’s approach with this novel is different than I’ve encountered before. Most of us don’t have the unpublished memoir of someone we know so well to use as a launching pad. Perhaps she can claim a new genre.

      • Susan Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:30 am

        Carol, I always think of the writers who skillfully merged fact and fiction to create a compelling story – Hemingway and Bukowski come to mind. You’re right, however, in that I had a very unique situation; a completely finished memoir at my disposal . . . although John rewrote parts of it as a novel using his pen name Jay Scioli, which is the name of the main character in A Portrait of Love and Honor. And I was John’s first editor . . . so there you have it! He and I have “told his story.”

        • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:36 am

          I am so pleased for you and John. The whole experience must put your heart in a very good place.

    • Susan Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:13 am

      Hi Mary, Thank you for your kind words and I hope you enjoy A Portrait of Love and Honor. I don’t claim to offer a new genre; just breaking the rules, I guess, in terms that this is a hybrid of sorts comprising memoir and fiction . . . and in some ways Ava Stuart is my alter ego . . . who I would have been in my early 40s, not my mid-20s when Ava meets “Jay.”

  4. Penelope James on April 30, 2015 at 11:58 am

    Susan Weidener’s book sounds like a love story, not just because of the title and the book’s subject, but in the story that led up to it. The fact that Susan picked up her late husband’s unpublished memoir and used parts from it in a contemporary novel shows dedication and love. Also, West Point adds cultural significance and relevance to that period in American life. Importantly, Susan made a marriage of her husband John Cavalieri’s memoir with her own work.

    • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:03 am

      A love story in all respects, Penelope. The West Point connection offers cultural significance, as you point out, and also potential for marketing.

      • Susan Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:24 am

        Carol, I might add that publishing the novel was a little scary in that Jay had a “love-hate” relationship with the USMA. Yet, in truth, John always told me that he credited the Academy with instilling in him the understanding that “a man has nothing without his honor.” Hopefully, John’s classmates will appreciate the “truth” of his story . . .

        • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:32 am

          The truth is seldom simple and often a little uncomfortable. You were brave to go there but if you hadn’t, I expect readers – including John’s classmates – would have seen through it.

    • Susan Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:19 am

      Thank you, Penelope. The West Point “connection” has already come through in that many of John’s classmates at the Academy have purchased the book and the Academy is making mention of it in their alumni magazine and Class Notes for the Class of ’71. As I’ve written before on blogs, etc., John’s story was so compelling and so honest, I felt it might strike a chord in others. And it is a way for a man’s memoir to be highlighted . . . . indeed John wrote this in the early 90s long before memoirs had come into vogue! The “marriage” of his work with my memoirs offers up a very detailed “portrait” of the love affair and marriage of two ordinary people who found in each other their “dream come true.”

  5. Laura Burtner on May 1, 2015 at 6:35 am

    Thanks for the advice. The first story I am writing for myself is a work of creative nonfiction. It will have elements of, memoir, interviews, and long tale-telling. I am gathering all the advice I can find. Yours is the first I have read that is from an author who has written in the genre to which I aspire for my initial effort.

    • Carol Bodensteiner on May 6, 2015 at 11:05 am

      I’m glad this post was useful to you, Laura. Good luck with your writing, and thanks for commenting.

    • Susan G. Weidener on May 6, 2015 at 11:54 am

      Good luck, Laura. It’s a lot of fun writing stories that are informed by our own life experiences . .. cultivating and tending those . .. and creating something uniquely ours, hopefully, with the power to reach readers’ hearts and minds.

Leave a Comment